# Thomas Nagel calls the idea of conscious AI “ridiculous”

- Published: 2026-11-18T15:02:40.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-19T10:05:01.741Z
- Section: Models
- Page: https://aidailyjournal.com/en/n/2026/11/18/thomas-nagel-calls-the-idea-of-conscious-ai-ridiculous/
- Sources: [Wired](https://wired.com/story/just-ridiculous-a-famed-philosopher-takes-on-ai-consciousness)

## Summary

In an interview with Wired, Thomas Nagel said he was impressed by the humanlike appearance of AI systems but called the idea that language models are, or may soon become, conscious “ridiculous.” The philosopher argues that functionalism—the idea that consciousness is independent of its physical substrate—may be wrong, because data centers have nothing in common with a nervous system’s physical characteristics that would be necessary for consciousness.

Nagel said language alone is not a natural manifestation of consciousness. He did not rule out the possibility that life forms physically and chemically different from humans could be conscious, but said it was premature to believe that it is already possible to create something with those characteristics. The interview took place the week Nagel, an NYU professor emeritus, received the $1 million Berggruen Prize for Philosophy & Culture.

## Why it matters (editorial interpretation)

Nagel’s position reinforces a relevant distinction when evaluating language models: humanlike linguistic behavior alone is not enough to establish consciousness. The debate also depends on hypotheses about which physical properties might be necessary for conscious experience.

_Summary written by AI Daily Journal in its own words, based on the sources above. For details, read the original articles._
